Between the 1909 and 1918 seasons, Chief Wilson hit the most homers for the Pirates, with 41 home runs.

	NAME	HR	G	AB	R	H	2B	3B	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	PA	TB	XBH	SH	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	wRC	WRAA	wOBA	wRC+	BRAA
1	Chief Wilson C. Wilson	41	755	2,812	346	795	101	87	383	148	22	318	60	3,066	1,193	229	84	.283	.324	.424	.748	404	68.3	.355	111	43.4
2	Honus Wagner H. Wagner	36	1,179	4,275	599	1,288	218	94	618	425	40	351	187	4,866	1,802	348	126	.301	.370	.422	.791	717	201.2	.381	131	172.3
3	Max Carey M. Carey	30	1,166	4,452	686	1,209	170	80	361	457	42	457	374	5,083	1,629	280	132	.272	.345	.366	.711	619	83	.346	111	58.5
4	Dots Miller D. Miller	21	710	2,621	347	697	118	63	389	197	17	235	80	2,962	1,004	202	127	.266	.321	.383	.704	353	29.3	.339	102	5.6
5	Tommy Leach T. Leach	13	452	1,671	307	431	71	24	161	181	4	175	72	1,919	589	108	63	.258	.332	.352	.684	223	20.7	.336	103	4
6	Bill Hinchman B. Hinchman	11	427	1,487	173	424	61	37	195	150	13	171	33	1,691	592	109	41	.285	.356	.398	.754	224	56.7	.365	130	51.5
7	Fred Clarke F. Clarke	10	397	1,388	227	400	65	33	180	186	12	86	53	1,653	561	108	67	.288	.377	.404	.781	243	69.4	.380	129	55.1
8	Bobby Byrne B. Byrne	8	590	2,344	381	649	126	42	195	248	22	144	97	2,661	883	176	47	.277	.352	.377	.728	344	47.8	.353	108	25.3
9	George Gibson G. Gibson	8	791	2,430	207	613	103	35	227	211	19	156	30	2,729	810	146	69	.252	.317	.333	.650	282	-6.9	.318	93	-24.9
10	Jim Viox J. Viox	7	506	1,703	214	465	76	24	190	222	12	112	39	1,989	610	107	52	.273	.361	.358	.719	250	41.3	.351	116	35.9
11	John Flynn J. Flynn	6	129	391	37	103	10	3	55	39	1	55	6	450	137	19	19	.263	.332	.350	.682	52	4.4	.336	99	-0.7
12	Ham Hyatt H. Hyatt	6	306	499	51	138	20	14	89	27	7	55	7	540	204	40	7	.277	.323	.409	.732	68	10.8	.351	111	6.4
13	George Cutshaw G. Cutshaw	5	126	463	56	132	16	10	68	27	1	18	25	520	183	31	29	.285	.326	.395	.721	62	11.3	.350	116	8.4
14	Doc Johnston D. Johnston	5	261	947	104	230	29	22	103	58	20	82	43	1,077	318	56	52	.243	.300	.336	.636	104	-3.9	.310	94	-5.9
15	William Fischer W. Fischer	4	137	358	36	99	16	3	31	37	2	22	12	405	133	23	8	.277	.348	.372	.719	49	10.4	.351	120	8.2
16	Ed Konetchy E. Konetchy	4	154	563	56	140	23	9	51	32	2	48	20	622	193	36	25	.249	.291	.343	.634	58	-6.7	.306	89	-7.5
17	Vin Campbell V. Campbell	4	139	375	54	121	12	6	31	34	4	30	23	427	157	22	14	.323	.385	.419	.804	65	19.7	.390	130	15.1
18	Alex McCarthy A. McCarthy	4	372	1,156	122	261	29	8	109	88	13	109	20	1,310	318	41	53	.226	.288	.275	.563	100	-43.4	.278	65	-51.3
19	Bill McKechnie B. McKechnie	4	325	1,041	105	248	22	19	96	67	4	68	27	1,166	320	45	54	.238	.287	.307	.594	97	-28.1	.291	74	-36.8
20	Mike Mitchell M. Mitchell	3	130	472	56	118	19	7	39	30	1	31	13	511	160	29	8	.250	.296	.339	.635	48	-5.9	.306	87	-7.4
21	Claude Hendrix C. Hendrix	3	121	261	40	70	16	11	25	7	0	49	1	272	117	30	4	.268	.287	.448	.736	33	1.8	.341	99	-0.2
22	Billy Southworth B. Southworth	2	64	246	37	84	5	7	43	26	2	9	19	275	109	14	1	.341	.409	.443	.852	44	17.5	.413	157	15.9
23	Bunny Brief B. Brief	2	36	115	15	25	5	1	11	15	2	21	4	141	38	8	9	.217	.318	.330	.649	15	1	.323	101	0.1
24	Lee King L. King	2	155	511	41	123	17	7	47	26	2	80	11	553	160	26	14	.241	.280	.313	.593	45	-8.6	.289	79	-12
25	Walter Schmidt W. Schmidt	2	241	690	56	157	14	5	59	38	5	43	14	760	187	21	27	.228	.273	.271	.544	51	-23	.268	65	-27