Between the 1916 and 1925 seasons, Max Carey hit the most home runs for the Pirates, with 48 home runs.

	NAME	HR	G	AB	R	H	2B	3B	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	CS	PA	TB	XBH	SH	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	wRC	WRAA	wOBA	wRC+	BRAA
1	Max Carey M. Carey	48	1,361	5,285	924	1,595	249	92	473	610	52	296	471		6,097	2,172	389	150	.302	.380	.411	.790	879	181.3	.375	121	151.6
2	Kiki Cuyler K. Cuyler	27	283	1,126	242	395	71	43	189	93	21	122	75		1,264	633	141	24	.351	.410	.562	.973	251	90	.438	149	81.3
3	Pie Traynor P. Traynor	27	611	2,394	403	734	104	59	374	154	13	100	85		2,606	1,037	190	45	.307	.352	.433	.785	354	26.6	.361	102	7.9
4	Glenn Wright G. Wright	25	306	1,230	177	366	60	28	232	58	1	84	17		1,322	557	113	33	.298	.330	.453	.783	172	4.5	.355	97	-4.1
5	Reb Russell R. Russell	21	154	511	100	165	32	15	133	34	10	39	7		568	290	68	13	.323	.377	.568	.944	106	35.1	.423	140	30.5
6	Clyde Barnhart C. Barnhart	20	569	1,914	295	576	89	55	342	194	5	108	29		2,184	835	164	71	.301	.367	.436	.803	313	38.4	.371	109	25.3
7	Charlie Grimm C. Grimm	18	770	2,837	301	812	117	65	369	184	11	162	29		3,101	1,113	200	69	.286	.332	.392	.724	359	-19.3	.337	91	-31.9
8	Carson Bigbee C. Bigbee	15	1,105	4,124	614	1,190	136	74	320	341	20	161	180		4,594	1,519	225	109	.289	.346	.368	.714	540	14.6	.339	99	-4.1
9	Earl Smith E. Smith	12	148	440	46	144	32	4	85	44	1	17	6		494	220	48	9	.327	.390	.500	.890	85	21.4	.405	128	17.6
10	Cotton Tierney C. Tierney	12	280	1,049	133	330	58	24	169	51	5	85	14		1,153	472	94	48	.315	.349	.450	.799	160	16.8	.365	106	10.2
11	George Grantham G. Grantham	8	114	359	74	117	24	6	52	50	3	29	14	4	423	177	38	11	.326	.413	.493	.906	77	21.5	.415	130	17.6
12	Eddie Moore E. Moore	8	220	782	159	245	38	12	91	102	4	41	26		910	331	58	22	.313	.395	.423	.819	140	22.9	.383	114	15.9
13	Possum Whitted P. Whitted	8	277	1,028	128	294	41	26	158	67	5	61	23		1,154	411	75	54	.286	.333	.400	.733	136	1.3	.341	103	1.8
14	George Cutshaw G. Cutshaw	8	494	1,813	207	498	65	30	219	91	5	61	92		2,003	647	103	94	.275	.311	.357	.668	200	-17.6	.318	91	-19.6
15	Billy Southworth B. Southworth	8	331	1,245	157	366	36	34	157	110	5	51	65		1,394	494	78	34	.294	.354	.397	.750	178	29.2	.358	121	29.5
16	Dave Robertson D. Robertson	6	60	230	29	74	18	3	48	12	2	16	4	5	252	116	27	8	.322	.361	.504	.865	40	8.7	.390	126	8.2
17	Bill Hinchman B. Hinchman	6	289	926	101	250	28	23	119	103	6	99	16		1,060	342	57	25	.270	.347	.369	.716	128	25.2	.349	120	20.5
18	Fred Nicholson F. Nicholson	5	129	313	41	107	18	9	36	24	0	42	11		344	158	32	7	.342	.389	.505	.894	59	21	.414	157	21.7
19	Casey Stengel C. Stengel	5	128	443	56	124	14	11	55	51	3	49	23		512	175	30	15	.280	.358	.395	.753	67	14.9	.362	128	14.4
20	Rabbit Maranville R. Maranville	4	601	2,459	345	697	103	56	245	185	6	168	81		2,705	924	163	55	.283	.335	.376	.711	302	-33.9	.332	86	-49.3
21	Wilbur Cooper W. Cooper	4	359	932	89	239	30	14	72	37	3	103	11		1,000	309	48	28	.256	.287	.332	.619	82	-30.5	.292	69	-34.4
22	William Fischer W. Fischer	4	137	358	36	99	16	3	31	37	2	22	12		405	133	23	8	.277	.348	.372	.719	49	10.4	.351	120	8.2
23	Johnny Rawlings J. Rawlings	3	158	574	70	163	25	4	60	33	2	37	9		622	205	32	13	.284	.325	.357	.682	64	-13.8	.320	78	-18.3
24	Ray Rohwer R. Rohwer	3	83	169	25	48	9	5	28	14	1	25	1		190	76	17	6	.284	.342	.450	.792	26	2	.361	102	0.5
25	Bill McKechnie B. McKechnie	3	166	568	47	140	16	10	56	28	2	29	19		620	185	29	22	.246	.284	.326	.610	51	-11.3	.296	79	-13.6