The Cincinnati Redlegs couldn't pull it off against the New York Giants, 5 to 4, on May 8, 1956.

Final

NYG

5

CIN

4

1

2

0

2

0

0

3

0

0

4

0

0

5

2

0

6

0

0

7

0

0

8

1

1

9

0

3

R

5

4

H

9

8

E

0

4

Player Stats

Giants

Redlegs

Batters

PlayerABRHRBIHRBBSOSBCSTB
Whitey Lockman LF5000000000
Alvin Dark SS5120000003
Willie Mays CF3221010002
Ray Katt C4111000001
Daryl Spencer 2B4110000002
Bill White 1B3011010101
Don Mueller RF3011000001
Foster Castleman 3B4000001000
Jim Hearn P4010002001
Don Liddle P0000000000
Totals355940231011

Pitchers

PlayerIPHRERBBSOHR
Jim Hearn (W)8.2844131
Don Liddle (S)0.1000000
Totals9.0844131
Some of the information used here was obtained free of charge from Retrosheet.