The New York Yankees couldn't pull it off against the Cleveland Indians, 5 to 4, on June 8, 1958.

Final

CLE

Indians

24-27

5

NYY

Yankees

32-14

4

1

0

0

2

2

1

3

2

0

4

0

2

5

0

1

6

1

0

7

0

0

8

0

0

9

0

0

R

5

4

H

11

9

E

1

0

Player Stats

Indians

Yankees

Batters

PlayerABRHRBIHRBBSOSBCSTB
Bobby Avila 2B5120000003
Billy Moran PR,2B0000000000
Roger Maris CF5111001003
Minnie Minoso LF5030002113
Preston Ward 1B4111011002
Rocky Colavito RF4112100004
Russ Nixon C2121110005
Dick Brown C1000001000
Chico Carrasquel 3B4010000002
Billy Harrell SS3000011100
Mudcat Grant P2000000000
Dick Tomanek P0000000000
Hoyt Wilhelm P1000001000
Totals3651152372122

Pitchers

PlayerIPHRERBBSOHR
Mudcat Grant4.1644352
Dick Tomanek (W)1.2100110
Hoyt Wilhelm (S)3.0200100
Totals9.0944562
Some of the information used here was obtained free of charge from Retrosheet.