Chad Pennington and Kurt Warner are tied for the most fumbles in a game, with 6 fumbles.

who has most forced fumbles in one game
Interpreted as:
Who has most forced fumbles in one regular-season game?
9/11/2005Pennington9/7/2003Warner12/8/2013Stafford10/18/2009Johnson12/23/2007Manning10/20/2002Ramsey12/2/2018Daniel12/17/2017Cutler11/27/2016Dalton10/23/2016Bradford11/30/2014McCoy11/23/2014Luck10/26/2014Vick12/16/2012Kaepernick12/16/2012Rivers10/30/2011McCoy10/2/2011Sanchez12/12/2010Sanchez11/28/2010Vick11/15/2009Freeman12/21/2008Roethlisberger10/19/2008O'Sullivan9/28/2008Warner66555544444444444444444
NAMEDATETMOPPFUMLOSTYDSTDRUSH YDSRUSH TDREC YDSREC TDKR YDSKR TDPR YDSPR TD
Chad PenningtonChad Pennington9/11/2005NYJNYJ@ KC
@
620000000000
Kurt WarnerKurt Warner9/7/2003STLSTL@ NYG
@
630000000000
Matthew StaffordMatthew Stafford12/8/2013DETDET@ PHI
@
51-10-10000000
Josh JohnsonJosh Johnson10/18/2009TBTBvs. CAR
vs.
51450450000000
Eli ManningEli Manning12/23/2007NYGNYG@ BUF
@
520000000000
Patrick RamseyPatrick Ramsey10/20/2002WASWAS@ GB
@
50000000000
Chase DanielChase Daniel12/2/2018CHICHI@ NYG
@
40-16040000000
Jay CutlerJay Cutler12/17/2017MIAMIA@ BUF
@
408080000000
Andy DaltonAndy Dalton11/27/2016CINCIN@ BAL
@
42110140000000
Sam BradfordSam Bradford10/23/2016MINMIN@ PHI
@
42-10-10000000
Colt McCoyColt McCoy11/30/2014WASWAS@ IND
@
41120120000000
Andrew LuckAndrew Luck11/23/2014INDINDvs. JAX
vs.
42490490000000
Michael VickMichael Vick10/26/2014NYJNYJvs. BUF
vs.
42690690000000
Colin KaepernickColin Kaepernick12/16/2012SFSF@ NE
@
40280280000000
Philip RiversPhilip Rivers12/16/2012SDSDvs. CAR
vs.
424040000000
Colt McCoyColt McCoy10/30/2011CLECLE@ SF
@
41300300000000
Mark SanchezMark Sanchez10/2/2011NYJNYJ@ BAL
@
433030000000
Mark SanchezMark Sanchez12/12/2010NYJNYJvs. MIA
vs.
41200200000000
Michael VickMichael Vick11/28/2010PHIPHI@ CHI
@
40440440000000
Josh FreemanJosh Freeman11/15/2009TBTB@ MIA
@
41350350000000
Ben RoethlisbergerBen Roethlisberger12/21/2008PITPIT@ TEN
@
42140140000000
J.T. O'SullivanJ.T. O'Sullivan10/19/2008SFSF@ NYG
@
41270270000000
Kurt WarnerKurt Warner9/28/2008ARIARI@ NYJ
@
430000000000
Cleo LemonCleo Lemon12/9/2007MIAMIA@ BUF
@
414040000000
Jon KitnaJon Kitna12/2/2007DETDET@ MIN
@
410000000000
Results may be incomplete. StatMuse has complete game-level data for fumbles going back to the 2001 season.

See Trending NFL Searches