Marvin Harrison scored the most receiving touchdowns for the Colts in his first 4 seasons, with 33 touchdowns.

Not what you're looking for?
who has the most rec td first 4 season colts
HarrisonMackeyHiltonWayneMooreMutschellerMoncriefBrooksFleenerBerryCollieGarconButlerPascalClarkCarrAllenDilgerMcCallMitchellJamesDawkinsDoughty3325242321211818171716161615141413121211101010
NAMEGPREC TDRECTRGREC YDSAVGREC YDS/GRUSH YDSATTYPCRUSH YDS/GRUSH TD
Marvin HarrisonMarvin Harrison60333111934,14113.369.01262.00.20
John MackeyJohn Mackey56251472,77518.949.6340.80.10
T.Y. HiltonT.Y. Hilton62242834934,41315.671.25596.10.90
Reggie WayneReggie Wayne61232213433,10914.151.0-41-4.0-0.10
Lenny MooreLenny Moore48211482,57317.453.62,1573586.044.920
Jim MutschellerJim Mutscheller48211101,84016.738.3000.00
Donte MoncriefDonte Moncrief53181522571,87512.335.41653.20.30
Bill BrooksBill Brooks60182333,63915.660.762134.81.00
Coby FleenerCoby Fleener60171833112,15411.835.9000.00
Raymond BerryRaymond Berry48171532,40015.750.0000.00
Austin CollieAustin Collie42161732581,84510.743.9120.50.00
Pierre GarconPierre Garcon58161883492,51913.443.44485.50.80
Ray ButlerRay Butler52161071,88117.636.21033.30.20
Zach PascalZach Pascal60151462491,84412.630.73557.00.60
Dallas ClarkDallas Clark52141211901,61813.431.1000.00
Roger CarrRoger Carr4614982,23322.848.5000.00
Dwayne AllenDwayne Allen4313911471,04511.524.3641.50.10
Ken DilgerKen Dilger62121421,82112.829.4000.00
Reese McCallReese McCall6212871,33215.321.5000.00
Tom MitchellTom Mitchell36113557716.516.0000.00
Edgerrin JamesEdgerrin James52102102831,7278.233.24,9131,1844.194.531
Sean DawkinsSean Dawkins63101832,70714.843.0000.00
Glenn DoughtyGlenn Doughty4610911,58417.434.4185209.34.00
Joseph AddaiJoseph Addai5891572011,2317.821.23,5258614.160.834
Pat BeachPat Beach5797074210.613.0000.00
StatMuse has season-level data for receiving touchdowns going back to the 1921 season.