4 quarterbacks are tied for the best passer rating in a game with 14+ passing attempts versus the Colts, with a 158.3 rating. The first three are Chad Pennington on November 16, 2003, Kerry Collins on December 22, 2002 and Craig Erickson on September 11, 1994.

highest passer rating in a game against the colts, minimum 14 pass attempts
Interpreted as:
highest passer rating by a player in a regular-season game against the colts, minimum 14 pass attempts
11/16/2003Pennington12/22/2002Collins9/11/1994Erickson11/3/1974Anderson12/2/1956Tittle12/17/1967Gabriel9/26/1954Van Brocklin12/21/2014Romo10/26/2014Roethlisberger11/19/1978Sipe12/16/2019Brees11/8/1964Bukich10/21/2001Brady12/14/2017Osweiler11/24/2016Roethlisberger10/23/2011Brees11/18/2001Brooks10/31/2004Green9/15/1963Tittle10/11/1981Anderson9/13/2020Minshew9/24/1978Ferguson9/26/1976Staubach158.3158.3158.3158.3155.8154.9153.8151.7150.6150.6148.9148.6148.3147.7146.0144.9144.1143.8143.7143.4142.3141.1140.9
NAMEDATETMOPPRATEATTCMPPCTYDSAVGTDTD%INTINT%SCKSCKY
Chad PenningtonChad Pennington11/16/2003NYJNYJ@ IND
@
158.3141178.621915.6321.400.0327
Kerry CollinsKerry Collins12/22/2002NYGNYG@ IND
@
158.3292379.336612.6413.800.000
Craig EricksonCraig Erickson9/11/1994TBTBvs. IND
vs.
158.3241979.231313.0312.500.000
Ken AndersonKen Anderson11/3/1974CINCIN@ BAL
@
158.3211781.029714.1314.300.0
Y.A. TittleY.A. Tittle12/2/1956SFSF@ BAL
@
155.8181477.828415.8211.100.0
Roman GabrielRoman Gabriel12/17/1967LALAvs. BAL
vs.
154.9221881.825711.7313.600.0
Norm Van BrocklinNorm Van Brocklin9/26/1954LALA@ BAL
@
153.8191578.929315.4210.500.0
Tony RomoTony Romo12/21/2014DALDALvs. IND
vs.
151.7201890.021810.9420.000.0111
Ben RoethlisbergerBen Roethlisberger10/26/2014PITPITvs. IND
vs.
150.6494081.652210.7612.200.000
Brian SipeBrian Sipe11/19/1978CLECLE@ BAL
@
150.6221568.230914.0418.200.0
Drew BreesDrew Brees12/16/2019NONOvs. IND
vs.
148.9302996.730710.2413.300.000
Rudy BukichRudy Bukich11/8/1964CHICHIvs. BAL
vs.
148.6151066.718512.3320.000.0
Tom BradyTom Brady10/21/2001NENE@ IND
@
148.3201680.020210.1315.000.000
Brock OsweilerBrock Osweiler12/14/2017DENDEN@ IND
@
147.7171270.619411.4211.800.000
Ben RoethlisbergerBen Roethlisberger11/24/2016PITPIT@ IND
@
146.0201470.022111.1315.000.000
Drew BreesDrew Brees10/23/2011NONOvs. IND
vs.
144.9353188.63259.3514.300.024
Aaron BrooksAaron Brooks11/18/2001NONOvs. IND
vs.
144.1221986.424911.329.100.0428
Trent GreenTrent Green10/31/2004KCKCvs. IND
vs.
143.8342779.438911.438.800.012
Y.A. TittleY.A. Tittle9/15/1963NYGNYG@ BAL
@
143.7231669.624310.6313.000.0
Ken AndersonKen Anderson10/11/1981CINCIN@ BAL
@
143.4272177.82579.5311.100.000
Gardner MinshewGardner Minshew9/13/2020JAXJAXvs. IND
vs.
142.3201995.01738.7315.000.0423
Joe FergusonJoe Ferguson9/24/1978BUFBUFvs. BAL
vs.
141.114964.315411.0214.300.0
Roger StaubachRoger Staubach9/26/1976DALDALvs. BAL
vs.
140.9282278.633912.127.100.0
Kellen ClemensKellen Clemens11/10/2013STLSTL@ IND
@
140.616956.324715.4212.500.0215
Fran TarkentonFran Tarkenton11/17/1963MINMINvs. BAL
vs.
140.6201470.022511.3210.000.0
Results may be incomplete. StatMuse has complete game-level data for passer rating and passing attempts going back to the 1950 season.

See Trending NFL Searches