The New England Patriots couldn't pull it off against the New York Jets, 34 to 31, on November 13, 2008.
1st quarter
NYJ
NE
Leon Washington 7-yard pass from Brett Favre (Jay Feely kick)
7
0
Stephen Gostkowski 42-yard field goal
7
3
Jay Feely 22-yard field goal
10
3
2nd quarter
NYJ
NE
Stephen Gostkowski 31-yard field goal
10
6
Leon Washington 92-yard kickoff return (Jay Feely kick)
17
6
Jerricho Cotchery 15-yard pass from Brett Favre (Jay Feely kick)
24
6
Jabar Gaffney 19-yard pass from Matt Cassel (Stephen Gostkowski kick)
24
13
3rd quarter
NYJ
NE
Benjamin Watson 10-yard pass from Matt Cassel (Matt Cassel pass to Jabar Gaffney for two-point conversion)
24
21
4th quarter
NYJ
NE
Stephen Gostkowski 47-yard field goal
24
24
Thomas Jones 1-yard run (Jay Feely kick)
31
24
Randy Moss 16-yard pass from Matt Cassel (Stephen Gostkowski kick)
31
31
OT
NYJ
NE
Jay Feely 34-yard field goal
34
31