The New York Titans couldn't pull it off against the Boston Patriots, 28 to 24, on September 17, 1960.
1st quarter
BOS
NYT
Walt Livingston 1-yard run (Gino Cappelletti kick)
7
0
Bill Shockley 23-yard field goal
7
3
2nd quarter
BOS
NYT
Dewey Bohling 8-yard pass from Al Dorow (Bill Shockley kick)
7
10
Ted Wegert 16-yard pass from Al Dorow (Bill Shockley kick)
7
17
3rd quarter
BOS
NYT
Thurlow Cooper 38-yard pass from Al Dorow (Bill Shockley kick)
7
24
Oscar Lofton 15-yard pass from Tom Greene (Gino Cappelletti kick)
14
24
4th quarter
BOS
NYT
Jim Colclough 6-yard pass from Butch Songin (Gino Cappelletti kick)
21
24
Chuck Shonta 52-yard fumble return (Gino Cappelletti kick)
28
24