| NO. | NAME | POS | HEIGHT | WEIGHT | DOB | AGE | COLLEGE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Arrowhead | 5'7" | 160 | None | ||||
| Napoleon Barrel | 5'8" | 200 | 12/25/1885 | 38 | Carlisle | ||
| Big Bear | 6'4" | 215 | None | ||||
| Peter Blackbear | 6'0" | 190 | 10/11/1899 | 24 | None | ||
| Leon Boutwell | 5'7" | 188 | 10/3/1892 | 31 | |||
| Ted Buffalo | 6'0" | 190 | 11/5/1901 | 22 | Haskell | ||
| Pete Calac | 5'10" | 190 | 5/13/1892 | 31 | West Virginia Wesleyan | ||
| Xavier Downwind | 6'0" | 200 | 12/24/1893 | 30 | Carlisle | ||
| Eagle Feather | None | ||||||
| Gray Horse | 5'8" | 190 | None | ||||
| Joe Guyon | 5'10" | 195 | 10/26/1892 | 31 | Georgia Tech | ||
| Al Jolley | 6'2" | 220 | 9/25/1899 | 24 | Kansas State | ||
| Nick Lassa | 5'10" | 205 | 7/11/1898 | 25 | Haskell | ||
| Chim Lingrel | 6'2" | 200 | 1/21/1899 | 24 | Miami (OH) | ||
| Joe Little Twig | 5'11" | 183 | Carlisle | ||||
| Ted Lone Wolf | 6'2" | 207 | None | ||||
| Emmett McLemore | 5'7" | 163 | 9/12/1899 | 24 | Pittsburg State | ||
| Ed Nason | 5'8" | 185 | 4/8/1899 | 24 | |||
| Bill Newashe | 5'11" | 200 | 10/5/1889 | 34 | Carlisle | ||
| Joe Pappio | 6'0" | 189 | 10/1/1902 | 21 | Haskell | ||
| Stan Powell | 5'11" | 185 | 2/11/1889 | 34 | Haskell | ||
| Jack Thorpe | 6'0" | 210 | None | ||||
| Jim Thorpe | 6'1" | 202 | 5/22/1887 | 36 | Carlisle | ||
| Woodchuck Welmas | 5'7" | 170 | 5/25/1891 | 32 | Carlisle |