The Chicago Black Hawks couldn't pull it off against the Toronto Maple Leafs, 3 to 2, on January 15, 1935.
1st period
TOR
CHI
Joe Primeau (PP) assisted by Charlie Conacher
1
0
Paul Thompson (PP) assisted by Howie Morenz and Doc Romnes
1
1
Bill Kendall (PP) assisted by Tom Cook, Lou Trudel, and Paul Thompson
1
2
2nd period
TOR
CHI
Bill Thoms (PP) assisted by Andy Blair
2
2
3rd period
TOR
CHI
Charlie Conacher (EV) unassisted
3
2