The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Montreal Canadiens, 3 to 2, in overtime on January 20, 1931.
Canadiens
14-7-3
Rangers
10-10-6
Team
MTL
NYR
1
2
0
3
OT
Total
1st period
Bill Cook assisted by Frank Boucher
Pit Lepine unassisted
Aurel Joliat unassisted
2nd period
Joe Jerwa assisted by Frank Boucher and Bill Cook
Gus Rivers unassisted