The Philadelphia Quakers couldn't pull it off against the Ottawa Senators, 5 to 4, in overtime on January 3, 1931.

Frank Finnigan unassisted

1

0

Syd Howe assisted by Wally Kilrea

1

1

Joe Lamb assisted by Leo Bourgeault

2

1

Hib Milks assisted by Syd Howe and Wally Kilrea

2

2

Hib Milks unassisted

2

3

Bill Touhey assisted by Frank Finnigan and Joe Lamb

3

3

Hec Kilrea assisted by Frank Finnigan

4

3

Joe Lamb assisted by Bill Touhey

5

3

Ron Lyons assisted by Syd Howe

5

4