The Toronto Maple Leafs couldn't pull it off against the New York Rangers, 3 to 2, on January 31, 1935.
2nd period
NYR
TOR
Andy Blair (EV) unassisted
0
1
Bert Connelly (EV) unassisted
1
1
Cecil Dillon (EV) unassisted
2
1
Cecil Dillon (EV) assisted by Murray Murdoch
3
1
3rd period
NYR
TOR
Buzz Boll (EV) assisted by Hec Kilrea
3
2