The Toronto Maple Leafs were decisively beaten by the New York Rangers, 5 to 2, on January 31, 1959.
1st period
NYR
TOR
Andy Bathgate (EV) assisted by Larry Popein
1
0
Red Sullivan (EV) assisted by Andy Hebenton
2
0
Larry Regan (EV) assisted by Gerry Ehman and Tim Horton
2
1
2nd period
NYR
TOR
Red Sullivan (EV) assisted by Bill Gadsby and Andy Hebenton
3
1
Andy Bathgate (EV) assisted by Larry Popein
4
1
Ron Stewart (EV) assisted by Bert Olmstead and Billy Harris
4
2
3rd period
NYR
TOR
Dean Prentice (EV) assisted by Larry Popein and John Hanna
5
2