The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Montreal Canadiens, 6 to 5, on January 9, 1944.
1st period
MTL
NYR
Murph Chamberlain (EV) assisted by Ray Getliffe
1
0
Elmer Lach (EV) assisted by Maurice Richard
2
0
Ray Getliffe (EV) unassisted
3
0
Dutch Hiller (PP) unassisted
3
1
2nd period
MTL
NYR
Ray Getliffe (PP) assisted by Buddy O'Connor
4
1
Bryan Hextall Sr. (EV) assisted by Bucko McDonald and Dutch Hiller
4
2
Dutch Hiller (EV) assisted by Bryan Hextall Sr. and Ott Heller
4
3
Murph Chamberlain (EV) assisted by Phil Watson
5
3
3rd period
MTL
NYR
Dutch Hiller (EV) assisted by Ott Heller
5
4
Gerry Heffernan (EV) assisted by Fern Majeau
6
4
Fern Gauthier (EV) unassisted
6
5