The New York Rangers fell to the Montreal Canadiens, 5 to 3, on October 19, 1958.

Lou Fontinato (EV) assisted by Larry Popein and Jim Bartlett

0

1

Wally Hergesheimer (EV) assisted by Camille Henry and Bill Gadsby

0

2

Jean Beliveau (PP) assisted by Bernie Geoffrion and Tom Johnson

1

2

Camille Henry (EV) assisted by Hank Ciesla and Andy Hebenton

1

3

Maurice Richard (PP) assisted by Bernie Geoffrion and Jean Beliveau

2

3

Henri Richard (EV) assisted by Maurice Richard and Bob Turner

3

3

Maurice Richard (EV) assisted by Henri Richard and Dickie Moore

4

3

Bernie Geoffrion (EV-EN) assisted by Jean Beliveau

5

3