The New York Rangers squeaked out a win over the Toronto Maple Leafs, 3 to 2, on October 26, 1958.

Dean Prentice (PP) assisted by Bill Gadsby and Andy Bathgate

0

1

Ron Stewart (PP) assisted by Rudy Migay and Frank Mahovlich

1

1

Larry Cahan (EV) unassisted

1

2

Eddie Shack (EV) assisted by Andy Hebenton and Red Sullivan

1

3

Ron Stewart (PP) assisted by Frank Mahovlich and Dick Duff

2

3