The Toronto Maple Leafs squeaked out a win over the New York Rangers, 4 to 3, on November 1, 1958.

Andy Bathgate (PP) assisted by Camille Henry and Bill Gadsby

1

0

Billy Harris (EV) assisted by Carl Brewer and Dick Duff

1

1

Bob Pulford (EV) assisted by Tim Horton and Frank Mahovlich

1

2

Andy Hebenton (EV) assisted by Red Sullivan and Eddie Shack

2

2

Jim Bartlett (SH) assisted by Les Colwill and Bill Gadsby

3

2

Ron Stewart (EV) assisted by Dick Duff and Billy Harris

3

3

Tim Horton (EV) assisted by Bert Olmstead and George Armstrong

3

4