The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Detroit Red Wings, 2 to 1, on November 2, 1958.
1st period
DET
NYR
Gordie Howe (PP) assisted by Nick Mickoski
1
0
2nd period
DET
NYR
Charlie Burns (EV) assisted by Marcel Pronovost and Johnny Wilson
2
0
3rd period
DET
NYR
Lou Fontinato (EV) assisted by John Hanna and Red Sullivan
2
1