The Montreal Canadiens couldn't pull it off against the New York Americans, 4 to 3, on November 24, 1928.
2nd period
NYA
MTL
Pit Lepine unassisted
0
1
Howie Morenz unassisted
0
2
Lionel Conacher unassisted
1
2
Johnny Sheppard assisted by Billy Burch
2
2
3rd period
NYA
MTL
Aurel Joliat assisted by Howie Morenz
2
3
Lionel Conacher unassisted
3
3
Joe Simpson unassisted
4
3