The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Toronto Maple Leafs, 4 to 3, on November 26, 1929.

Red Horner assisted by Hap Day

1

0

Eric Pettinger unassisted

2

0

Bill Cook assisted by Frank Boucher

2

1

Murray Murdoch assisted by Paul Thompson

2

2

Charlie Conacher assisted by Red Horner

3

2

Ace Bailey assisted by Red Horner

4

2

Bun Cook assisted by Frank Boucher

4

3