The New York Rangers emerged victorious over the Montreal Canadiens, 5 to 3, on November 26, 1958.

Jean Beliveau (PP) assisted by Don Marshall and Tom Johnson

1

0

Dickie Moore (PP) assisted by Jean Beliveau and Maurice Richard

2

0

Camille Henry (EV) assisted by Andy Bathgate

2

1

Red Sullivan (PP) assisted by Camille Henry and Bill Gadsby

2

2

Maurice Richard (EV) unassisted

3

2

Andy Hebenton (PP) assisted by Red Sullivan and Bill Gadsby

3

3

Jim Bartlett (EV) assisted by Harry Howell and Les Colwill

3

4

Andy Hebenton (EV) assisted by John Hanna and Bill Gadsby

3

5