The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Chicago Black Hawks, 4 to 3, on November 6, 1943.
2nd period
CHI
NYR
Bill Thoms (EV) unassisted
1
0
Grant Warwick (EV) assisted by Charlie Sands and Bill Warwick
1
1
Bill Mosienko (EV) assisted by Doug Bentley and Bill Thoms
2
1
Frank Boucher (EV) assisted by Bill Gooden and Jack McDonald
2
2
3rd period
CHI
NYR
Mush March (EV) assisted by Fido Purpur and Clint Smith
3
2
Bill Gooden (EV) assisted by Frank Boucher and Jack McDonald
3
3
Doug Bentley (EV) assisted by Bill Mosienko
4
3