The New York Rangers dominated the Toronto Maple Leafs, 5 to 1, on December 21, 1958.

Red Sullivan (PP) assisted by Camille Henry and Andy Bathgate

0

1

Hank Ciesla (EV) assisted by Les Colwill and John Hanna

0

2

Barry Cullen (EV) assisted by Bob Pulford and Brian Cullen

1

2

Bill Gadsby (EV) assisted by Andy Bathgate and Eddie Shack

1

3

Larry Popein (EV) assisted by Eddie Shack and Harry Howell

1

4

Andy Hebenton (EV) assisted by Dean Prentice

1

5