The New York Rangers tied the Toronto Maple Leafs, 5 to 5, in overtime on February 1, 1934.

Charlie Conacher (EV) assisted by Red Horner and King Clancy

1

0

Hap Day (EV) unassisted

2

0

Baldy Cotton (EV) assisted by Ken Doraty

3

0

Cecil Dillon (EV) assisted by Bun Cook

3

1

Charlie Conacher (EV) assisted by Busher Jackson and Joe Primeau

4

1

Earl Seibert (EV) assisted by Bun Cook

4

2

Bun Cook (EV) assisted by Bill Cook and Frank Boucher

4

3

Bill Cook (EV) assisted by Frank Boucher and Ching Johnson

4

4

Joe Primeau (EV) assisted by Hap Day

5

4

Bun Cook (EV) assisted by Cecil Dillon and Frank Boucher

5

5