The Chicago Black Hawks couldn't pull it off against the New York Rangers, 2 to 1, on February 10, 1935.
1st period
NYR
CHI
Murray Murdoch (SH) unassisted
1
0
2nd period
NYR
CHI
Murray Murdoch (EV) assisted by Earl Seibert
2
0
3rd period
NYR
CHI
Norm Locking (EV) assisted by Paul Thompson and Rosie Couture
2
1