The New York Rangers fell to the Chicago Black Hawks, 5 to 3, on March 11, 1959.

Andy Bathgate (EV) assisted by Dean Prentice and Eddie Shack

0

1

Earl Balfour (SH) assisted by Glen Skov

1

1

Bobby Hull (EV) assisted by Eric Nesterenko

2

1

Tod Sloan (PP) assisted by Ted Lindsay and Ed Litzenberger

3

1

Andy Bathgate (PP) assisted by Dean Prentice and Bill Gadsby

3

2

Ted Lindsay (EV) assisted by Tod Sloan and Ed Litzenberger

4

2

John McKenzie (EV) assisted by Danny Lewicki and Kenny Wharram

5

2

Andy Bathgate (EV) assisted by Dean Prentice and Larry Popein

5

3