The Toronto Maple Leafs couldn't pull it off against the Detroit Red Wings, 4 to 3, in overtime on March 20, 1996.

Mike Gartner (PP) assisted by Mathieu Schneider and Larry Murphy

0

1

Vyacheslav Kozlov (EV) assisted by Igor Larionov and Bob Rouse

1

1

Vladimir Konstantinov (EV) unassisted

2

1

Brandon Convery (PP) assisted by Larry Murphy and Mathieu Schneider

2

2

Tie Domi (EV) assisted by Kelly Fairchild and Todd Gill

2

3

Dino Ciccarelli (EV) unassisted

3

3

Darren McCarty (PP) assisted by Paul Coffey and Keith Primeau

4

3