The Columbus Blue Jackets couldn't pull it off against the New York Islanders, 4 to 3, in overtime on March 27, 2010.
1st period
NYI
CBJ
Kyle Okposo (EV) assisted by Matt Moulson
1
0
Sean Bergenheim (EV) assisted by Tim Jackman and Freddy Meyer
2
0
2nd period
NYI
CBJ
R.J. Umberger (PP) assisted by Rick Nash and Anton Stralman
2
1
3rd period
NYI
CBJ
Rick Nash (EV) assisted by Kristian Huselius and Antoine Vermette
2
2
Grant Clitsome (EV) assisted by Chris Clark and Samuel Pahlsson
2
3
Jon Sim (EV) assisted by Jack Hillen and Josh Bailey
3
3
OT
NYI
CBJ
Josh Bailey (EV) assisted by John Tavares and Mark Streit
4
3