The New York Americans tied the Toronto Maple Leafs, 5 to 5, in overtime on January 10, 1935.

Charlie Conacher (EV) unassisted

1

0

Eddie Burke (PP) assisted by Lorne Carr and Sweeney Schriner

1

1

Art Chapman (PP) assisted by Sweeney Schriner and Alex Smith

1

2

Sweeney Schriner (EV) assisted by Art Chapman and Lorne Carr

1

3

Joe Primeau (PP) assisted by Charlie Conacher, Baldy Cotton, Andy Blair, and Busher Jackson

2

3

Busher Jackson (EV) assisted by King Clancy

3

3

Charlie Conacher (EV) assisted by Busher Jackson

4

3

Pep Kelly (EV) assisted by Red Horner

5

3

Sweeney Schriner (PP) assisted by Art Chapman, Bill Brydge, and Lorne Carr

5

4

Charley McVeigh (EV) assisted by Normie Himes and Red Conn

5

5