The Chicago Black Hawks couldn't pull it off against the Detroit Red Wings, 3 to 2, on January 21, 1959.
2nd period
DET
CHI
Johnny Wilson (PP) assisted by Jack McIntyre and Alex Delvecchio
1
0
Ron Murphy (EV) assisted by Bobby Hull
1
1
Norm Johnson (EV) unassisted
1
2
Jack McIntyre (PP) assisted by Gordie Howe and Nick Mickoski
2
2
3rd period
DET
CHI
Charlie Burns (EV) assisted by Pete Goegan and Nick Mickoski
3
2