The New York Americans couldn't pull it off against the New York Rangers, 3 to 2, on January 24, 1933.
1st period
NYR
NYA
George Patterson assisted by Wilf Starr and Merlyn Phillips
0
1
Doug Brennan unassisted
1
1
Ching Johnson assisted by Bill Cook and Frank Boucher
2
1
2nd period
NYR
NYA
Normie Himes assisted by Nick Wasnie and Johnny Sheppard
2
2
3rd period
NYR
NYA
Frank Boucher assisted by Bill Cook and Bun Cook
3
2