The Toronto Maple Leafs couldn't pull it off against the Boston Bruins, 6 to 5, on November 16, 1929.
1st period
BOS
TOR
Dit Clapper assisted by Dutch Gainor
1
0
Charlie Conacher assisted by Eric Pettinger
1
1
Dit Clapper assisted by Eddie Shore
2
1
Dutch Gainor assisted by Dit Clapper
3
1
Dutch Gainor assisted by Cooney Weiland
4
1
2nd period
BOS
TOR
Lionel Hitchman unassisted
5
1
Baldy Cotton unassisted
5
2
3rd period
BOS
TOR
Andy Blair assisted by Ace Bailey and Danny Cox
5
3
Gord Brydson assisted by Joe Primeau
5
4
Charlie Conacher assisted by Baldy Cotton and Eric Pettinger
5
5
Dutch Gainor unassisted
6
5