The Toronto Maple Leafs tied the New York Rangers, 4 to 4, on December 13, 1958.

Andy Bathgate (PP) assisted by Camille Henry and Red Sullivan

1

0

Billy Harris (EV) assisted by Carl Brewer

1

1

Billy Harris (EV) assisted by Marc Reaume

1

2

George Armstrong (EV) assisted by Bob Pulford

1

3

Red Sullivan (PP) assisted by Andy Hebenton

2

3

Andy Hebenton (PP) assisted by Eddie Shack and Red Sullivan

3

3

Dean Prentice (EV) unassisted

4

3

Dick Duff (PP) assisted by Tim Horton and Billy Harris

4

4