The New York Americans couldn't pull it off against the Boston Bruins, 5 to 4, in overtime on December 14, 1933.
1st period
BOS
NYA
Lionel Hitchman (EV) assisted by Nels Stewart
1
0
Lloyd Gross (EV) assisted by Charley McVeigh
1
1
2nd period
BOS
NYA
Bill Brydge (EV) assisted by Lloyd Klein and Red Conn
1
2
Walter Jackson (EV) assisted by Normie Himes and Red Dutton
1
3
Art Chapman (EV) assisted by Harry Oliver and Alex Smith
2
3
Marty Barry (EV) assisted by Alex Smith and Art Chapman
3
3
3rd period
BOS
NYA
Normie Himes (EV) assisted by Ron Martin
3
4
Marty Barry (EV) assisted by Harry Oliver
4
4
OT
BOS
NYA
Art Chapman (EV) assisted by Harry Oliver
5
4