The New York Rangers tied the Chicago Black Hawks, 3 to 3, on December 14, 1958.

Ron Murphy (EV) assisted by Al Arbour

1

0

Red Sullivan (EV) assisted by Camille Henry and Andy Hebenton

1

1

Pierre Pilote (PP) assisted by Ron Murphy and Tod Sloan

2

1

Ron Murphy (EV) assisted by Moose Vasko and Bobby Hull

3

1

Camille Henry (PP) assisted by Bill Gadsby and Red Sullivan

3

2

Andy Bathgate (EV) assisted by Larry Popein and Dean Prentice

3

3