The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the Toronto Maple Leafs, 4 to 3, on December 23, 1945.
1st period
TOR
NYR
Sweeney Schriner (EV) assisted by Billy Taylor Sr.
1
0
Ab DeMarco Sr. (EV) assisted by Grant Warwick
1
1
Billy Taylor Sr. (EV) assisted by Babe Pratt and Gus Bodnar
2
1
Ott Heller (EV) assisted by Phil Watson and Lynn Patrick
2
2
2nd period
TOR
NYR
Gaye Stewart (EV) assisted by Bob Goldham
3
2
3rd period
TOR
NYR
Edgar Laprade (EV) assisted by Phil Watson
3
3
Babe Pratt (EV) assisted by Bob Davidson
4
3