The New York Americans couldn't pull it off against the Toronto Maple Leafs, 4 to 3, in overtime on December 27, 1934.
1st period
TOR
NYA
Buzz Boll (EV) assisted by Bill Thoms
1
0
Joe Primeau (EV) assisted by Busher Jackson and Flash Hollett
2
0
Buzz Boll (EV) unassisted
3
0
2nd period
TOR
NYA
Charley McVeigh (EV) assisted by Normie Himes and Harry Oliver
3
1
Lorne Carr (PP) assisted by Sweeney Schriner and Art Chapman
3
2
3rd period
TOR
NYA
Eddie Burke (PP) assisted by Normie Himes, Charley McVeigh, and Lloyd Klein
3
3
OT
TOR
NYA
Pep Kelly (EV) assisted by Baldy Cotton
4
3