The Pittsburgh Pirates couldn't pull it off against the Boston Bruins, 4 to 3, in overtime on December 4, 1926.
2nd period
BOS
PIR
Hib Milks assisted by Ty Arbour
0
1
Herb Drury unassisted
0
2
3rd period
BOS
PIR
Hib Milks assisted by Ty Arbour
0
3
Eddie Shore unassisted
1
3
Eddie Shore unassisted
2
3
Jimmy Herberts unassisted
3
3
OT
BOS
PIR
Harry Oliver unassisted
4
3