The Montreal Canadiens couldn't pull it off against the Ottawa Senators, 3 to 2, in overtime on February 14, 1920.
1st period
SEN
MTL
Newsy Lalonde assisted by Amos Arbour
0
1
Sprague Cleghorn unassisted
1
1
Amos Arbour assisted by Newsy Lalonde
1
2
2nd period
SEN
MTL
Frank Nighbor assisted by Jack Darragh
2
2
OT
SEN
MTL
Cy Denneny assisted by Georges Boucher
3
2