The New York Rangers couldn't pull it off against the New York Islanders, 3 to 2, on April 11, 2006.
1st period
NYI
NYR
Miroslav Satan (EV) assisted by Wyatt Smith and Sean Bergenheim
1
0
2nd period
NYI
NYR
Chris Campoli (EV) assisted by Jason Blake and Robert Nilsson
2
0
Miroslav Satan (PP) assisted by Radek Martinek and Mike York
3
0
3rd period
NYI
NYR
Michael Nylander (EV) assisted by Michal Rozsival and Jaromir Jagr
3
1
Petr Prucha (PP) assisted by Petr Sykora and Jaromir Jagr
3
2