best performing insurance stocks 2000 to 2025

W R Berkley (WRB) had the highest return between 2000 and 2025 by a US stock in the Insurance Industry, returning 8,415.3%.

ASSETYEARS% RETURN
W R Berkley (WRB)
2000-2025
8,415.32%
Universal Insurance (UVE)
2000-2025
8,040.54%
Arch Capital (ACGL)
2000-2025
7,055.54%
Progressive (PGR)
2000-2025
6,784.7%
Brown & Brown (BRO)
2000-2025
4,254.14%
HCI (HCI)
2000-2025
4,203.9%
RLI (RLI)
2000-2025
3,656.57%
Chubb (CB)
2000-2025
3,495.96%
Arthur J Gallagher (AJG)
2000-2025
3,348.02%
Renaissancere (RNR)
2000-2025
2,825.04%
Investors Title (ITIC)
2000-2025
2,554.32%
Old Republic International (ORI)
2000-2025
2,442.28%
American Financial (AFG)
2000-2025
2,289.38%
Everest (EG)
2000-2025
2,253.24%
Kinsale Capital (KNSL)
2000-2025
2,140.95%
White Mountains Insurance (WTM)
2000-2025
1,810.46%
Erie Indemnity (ERIE)
2000-2025
1,743.48%
Sun Life Financial (SLF)
2000-2025
1,716.11%
Selective Insurance (SIGI)
2000-2025
1,580.51%
Travelers Companies (TRV)
2000-2025
1,572.73%
Allstate (ALL)
2000-2025
1,526.59%
Safety Insurance (SAFT)
2000-2025
1,517.17%
Primerica (PRI)
2000-2025
1,509.52%
Aflac (AFL)
2000-2025
1,476.73%
Manulife Financial (MFC)
2000-2025
1,418.82%