Answered November 19th, 2017

Nathan Peterman had a rough NFL debut. He became the first Bills QB with 5 INTs in a game since 1983.

Who was the last Bills quarterback with 5 interceptions in a game?
Interpreted as:
Who was the last Bills quarterback with 5 passing interceptions in a regular season game?
11/19/2017Peterman11/27/1983Ferguson11/21/1982Ferguson9/7/1980Ferguson11/10/1974Ferguson9/24/1967Flores9/18/1960O'Connell5555655
NAMEDATETMOPPINTCOMPATTPCTYDSAVGTDTD%INT%SCKSCKYRATE
Nathan Peterman11/19/2017BUF
@
LAC
561442.9664.700.035.70017.9
Joe Ferguson11/27/1983BUF
@
RAM
5204445.52335.324.511.41137.6
Joe Ferguson11/21/1982BUF
vs.
MIA
5122842.91405.000.017.911419
Joe Ferguson9/7/1980BUF
vs.
MIA
5203262.51986.213.115.60050.8
Joe Ferguson11/10/1974BUF
vs.
HOU
6102835.71103.900.021.4008.6
Tom Flores9/24/1967BUF
vs.
BOS
5113036.71595.300.016.70015.1
Tommy O'Connell9/18/1960BUF
vs.
DEN
5132356.52189.528.721.70078.1
StatMuse has game-level passing, rushing, and receiving stats dating back to the 1950 season. All other stats date back to the 1960 season.