Charlie Gogolak has kicked the most extra points in a game, with 9 points against the Giants on November 27, 1966.

most extra points made in a game
Interpreted as:
most extra points made by a player in a regular-season game
11/27/1966Gogolak1/3/2021Bass9/8/2019Tucker9/18/2014Bryant12/15/2013Succop11/18/2012Gostkowski10/23/2011Kasay11/15/2010Akers10/24/2010Janikowski10/18/2009Gostkowski11/18/2007Gostkowski9/23/2007Akers10/24/2004Tynes11/10/1996Lohmiller10/18/1992Cofer11/10/1991Lohmiller10/29/1989Breech11/17/1985Leahy10/12/1980Septien9/9/1979Smith98888888888888888888
Results may be incomplete. StatMuse has complete game-level data for extra points going back to the 1960 season.

See Trending NFL Searches