Mike Gartner has the most career goals versus the Penguins, with 56 scored.

most goals by a player scored against pit all-time

	NAME	G	GP	A	P	+/-	PIM	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%	FOW	FO	FOW%	HIT	BKS	TKA	GVA	TOI/GP
1	Mike Gartner M. Gartner	56	94	46	102	+4	114	20	18	2	0	6	1	360	15.6
2	Bryan Trottier B. Trottier	47	82	58	105	+33	58	18	22	2	1	5	0	214	22.0
3	Guy Lafleur G. Lafleur	46	70	55	101	+49	25	12	18	1	0	11	0	241	19.1
4	Wayne Gretzky W. Gretzky	44	57	80	124	+52	14	7	28	4	6	8	0	212	20.8
5	Bobby Clarke B. Clarke	44	76	64	108	+69	69	9	15	6	5	6	1	202	21.8
6	Alex Ovechkin A. Ovechkin	43	80	33	76	+4	48	23	12	1	0	3	0	372	11.6	3	15	20.0	279	40	31	53	21:01
7	Mike Bossy M. Bossy	42	53	31	73	+13	12	17	17	2	1	10	1	195	21.5
8	Marcel Dionne M. Dionne	41	82	62	103	+7	40	8	19	2	0	4	0	343	12.0
9	Phil Esposito P. Esposito	40	65	44	84	+11	54	16	16	1	0	8	0	288	13.9
10	Gilbert Perreault G. Perreault	39	69	51	90	+21	16	11	14	0	1	10	0	193	20.2
11	Mats Sundin M. Sundin	38	54	43	81	+19	32	9	13	3	1	6	1	162	23.5	344	638	53.9	20	13	5	12	19:50
12	Pat LaFontaine P. LaFontaine	37	67	39	76	-4	30	17	16	1	0	3	0	223	16.6
13	Mark Messier M. Messier	37	85	76	113	+17	153	12	20	2	3	4	0	232	15.9	205	371	55.3	6	6	16	10	19:59
14	Bill Barber B. Barber	37	58	30	67	+40	38	9	10	4	1	4	0	251	14.7
15	Darryl Sittler D. Sittler	37	71	46	83	+6	69	10	11	0	1	6	0	270	13.7
16	John MacLean J. MacLean	36	78	32	68	+9	99	13	9	2	1	6	0	203	17.7	2	3	66.7	2	1	3	2	16:00
17	Butch Goring B. Goring	34	80	37	71	+11	12	9	16	6	1	3	0	184	18.5
18	Mike Ridley M. Ridley	33	62	43	76	-2	26	14	7	0	3	3	0	129	25.6
19	Peter Stastny P. Stastny	32	51	40	72	-3	33	13	21	2	1	5	0	132	24.2
20	Dennis Maruk D. Maruk	32	57	34	66	-9	74	8	12	2	0	1	0	164	19.5
21	Stan Mikita S. Mikita	32	52	39	71	+28	51	6	13	1	1	6	0	156	20.5
22	Mike Knuble M. Knuble	31	66	16	47	+14	73	7	5	1	0	6	1	155	20.0	17	46	37.0	84	35	14	16	17:25
23	Tim Kerr T. Kerr	31	54	30	61	+14	76	14	11	0	0	6	0	189	16.4
24	Brad Park B. Park	31	64	59	90	+64	90	15	24	2	1	6	0	215	14.4
25	Jean Ratelle J. Ratelle	31	67	46	77	+33	12	6	12	0	0	5	0	185	16.8