Between the 1964-65 and 1973-74 seasons, Bryan Watson had the most penalty minutes, with 1,301 minutes in the box.

most penalty minutes by a player 1964-65 to 1973-74

	NAME	PIM	GP	G	A	P	+/-	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	S	S%
1	Bryan Watson B. Watson	1,301	520	12	75	87	-33	1	4	1	2	2	445	2.7
2	John Ferguson J. Ferguson	1,091	441	127	131	258	+65	23	24	0	0	27	1,009	12.6
3	Gary Bergman G. Bergman	1,065	687	58	241	299	+33	12	44	3	11	10	1,336	4.3
4	Reg Fleming R. Fleming	1,015	485	87	106	193	-57	12	12	3	4	10	887	9.8
5	Ted Harris T. Harris	952	714	29	161	190	+105	2	8	1	2	2	679	4.3
6	Barclay Plager B. Plager	950	472	40	154	194	+44	9	35	3	7	5	704	5.7
7	Keith Magnuson K. Magnuson	948	360	7	93	100	+159	0	3	0	3	1	319	2.2
8	Carol Vadnais C. Vadnais	911	460	91	160	251	-15	27	54	1	3	13	1,213	7.5
9	Gary Dornhoefer G. Dornhoefer	894	486	125	217	342	+4	21	59	5	3	17	929	13.5
10	Don Awrey D. Awrey	877	602	25	103	128	+100	3	6	0	3	1	707	3.5
11	Bob Baun B. Baun	875	530	14	109	123	+52	0	10	0	1	0	789	1.8
12	Terry Harper T. Harper	839	624	12	121	133	+184	0	1	0	2	2	537	2.2
13	Vic Hadfield V. Hadfield	836	692	240	292	532	+37	82	80	0	0	34	2,148	11.2
14	Ed Van Impe E. Van Impe	833	563	26	93	119	+42	5	9	0	2	5	737	3.5
15	Eddie Shack E. Shack	813	654	173	152	325	-79	43	38	0	0	30	1,522	11.4
16	Bobby Orr B. Orr	801	541	213	522	735	+484	55	194	13	28	22	2,544	8.4
17	Gilles Marotte G. Marotte	792	627	45	212	257	-119	12	56	1	7	4	1,548	2.9
18	John McKenzie J. McKenzie	790	540	183	242	425	+35	53	84	3	2	29	1,187	15.4
19	Tim Horton T. Horton	745	673	50	180	230	+115	15	32	2	10	8	1,251	4.0
20	Arnie Brown A. Brown	734	675	44	141	185	-113	4	14	0	2	6	1,135	3.9
21	Pete Stemkowski P. Stemkowski	711	673	154	255	409	+77	21	27	3	4	23	1,860	8.3
22	Claude Larose C. Larose	710	639	164	180	344	+18	20	27	4	3	24	1,523	10.8
23	Tracy Pratt T. Pratt	691	372	10	64	74	-61	0	2	0	2	1	296	3.4
24	Derek Sanderson D. Sanderson	686	389	135	159	294	+135	11	9	24	19	14	1,082	12.5
25	Bert Marshall B. Marshall	662	545	10	101	111	-56	2	21	0	3	0	669	1.5