Between the 1990-91 and 1999-00 seasons, Tie Domi had the most penalty minutes, with 2,614 minutes in the box.

Interpreted as:

most penalty minutes by a player 1990-91 to 1999-00

	NAME	PIM	GP	G	A	P	+/-	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%	FOW	FO	FOW%	HIT	BKS	TKA	GVA	TOI/GP
1	Tie Domi T. Domi	2,614	626	55	86	141	-46	2	2	0	0	7	0	569	9.7	1	4	25.0	85	10	5	32	9:58
2	Rob Ray R. Ray	2,588	687	32	40	72	-30	2	1	0	0	3	0	277	11.6	0	0		55	4	2	16	4:13
3	Gino Odjick G. Odjick	2,391	539	58	66	124	-24	6	5	0	0	13	0	681	8.5	1	3	33.3	67	10	18	22	11:29
4	Craig Berube C. Berube	2,158	712	48	73	121	-46	2	2	0	0	5	0	509	9.4	1	4	25.0	111	7	12	23	8:00
5	Bob Probert B. Probert	2,089	585	98	147	245	+7	23	26	0	0	16	1	768	12.8	13	32	40.6	87	15	14	17	10:28
6	Mike Peluso M. Peluso	1,936	456	38	52	90	-15	6	2	0	0	2	0	311	12.2
7	Lyle Odelein L. Odelein	1,852	713	34	153	187	+84	10	42	1	3	5	0	770	4.4	0	0		57	91	46	44	17:48
8	Jeff Odgers J. Odgers	1,832	619	63	55	118	-92	15	9	0	0	4	0	567	11.1	1	2	50.0	64	8	3	11	5:23
9	Marty McSorley M. McSorley	1,823	573	59	173	232	-9	9	51	7	11	4	0	954	6.2	0	0		35	11	4	10	14:01
10	Stu Grimson S. Grimson	1,780	623	13	19	32	-38	1	0	0	0	2	0	180	7.2	0	0		55	2	3	5	5:13
11	Kelly Chase K. Chase	1,773	415	16	33	49	-13	0	1	0	0	4	0	223	7.2	0	1	0.0	8	2	3	4	7:46
12	Ronnie Stern R. Stern	1,768	572	72	83	155	-14	2	1	3	2	9	1	716	10.1	1	3	33.3	142	14	14	18	9:07
13	Shane Churla S. Churla	1,706	366	22	36	58	-45	4	5	0	0	2	0	270	8.1
14	Dave Manson D. Manson	1,682	727	73	206	279	-16	34	80	2	5	6	0	1,611	4.5	0	0		80	33	14	57	15:45
15	Chris Chelios C. Chelios	1,602	755	96	427	523	+173	38	215	7	24	14	0	2,041	4.7	0	0		120	86	47	113	25:16
16	Pat Verbeek P. Verbeek	1,589	750	286	317	603	+40	109	110	1	2	44	2	1,888	15.1	0	1	0.0	148	8	25	32	16:04
17	Bryan Marchment B. Marchment	1,573	577	27	92	119	-20	4	16	1	4	2	0	644	4.2	0	0		127	51	15	30	18:55
18	Kris King K. King	1,566	710	56	75	131	-45	0	1	2	2	9	0	679	8.2	0	0		60	7	2	5	8:31
19	Brad May B. May	1,556	577	91	110	201	-26	14	22	0	1	18	1	901	10.1	0	3	0.0	117	10	16	16	10:24
20	Ken Baumgartner K. Baumgartner	1,545	552	9	30	39	-65	0	0	0	0	1	0	210	4.3
21	Ulf Samuelsson U. Samuelsson	1,517	679	29	149	178	+115	3	25	0	8	6	1	707	4.1	0	0		69	81	16	34	15:40
22	Randy McKay R. McKay	1,486	675	123	151	274	+95	20	15	0	2	23	2	930	13.2	0	2	0.0	144	16	30	34	15:39
23	Paul Laus P. Laus	1,479	460	9	53	62	+25	0	4	0	2	1	0	303	3.0	0	1	0.0	106	15	22	11	7:46
24	Matthew Barnaby M. Barnaby	1,479	399	61	93	154	+4	5	12	0	0	9	1	555	11.0	33	75	44.0	99	10	14	37	12:38
25	Brendan Shanahan B. Shanahan	1,471	741	376	355	731	+75	129	143	16	9	62	3	2,645	14.2	12	24	50.0	104	34	23	58	18:35