Between the 1919-20 and 1928-29 seasons, Clint Benedict had the most wins by a goalie, with 163 wins.

NHL most regular-season wins by goalie 1919-20 to 1928-29

	NAME	W	GP	L	T	GA	GAA	SHO	MIN
1	Clint Benedict C. Benedict	163	308	118	27	658	2.06	54	19123
2	John Ross Roach J. Ross Roach	119	266	120	27	704	2.57	26	16433
3	Alec Connell A. Connell	105	198	61	32	301	1.45	57	12470
4	Jake Forbes J. Forbes	82	200	109	9	568	2.77	19	12303
5	Georges Vezina G. Vezina	81	151	64	5	471	3.07	11	9192
6	George Hainsworth G. Hainsworth	76	132	32	24	158	1.15	49	8269
7	Roy Worters R. Worters	68	161	71	22	298	1.79	35	9988
8	Lorne Chabot L. Chabot	61	124	41	19	202	1.59	31	7611
9	Hal Winkler H. Winkler	35	75	26	14	123	1.57	21	4698
10	Hap Holmes H. Holmes	30	85	45	10	179	2.02	17	5324
11	Charles Stewart C. Stewart	30	77	41	5	194	2.45	10	4742
12	Tiny Thompson T. Thompson	26	44	13	5	52	1.15	12	2710
13	Hugh Lehman H. Lehman	20	48	24	4	136	2.68	6	3045
14	Dolly Dolson D. Dolson	19	44	16	9	63	1.37	10	2750
15	Joe Miller J. Miller	17	72	43	12	157	2.09	16	4501
16	Howard Lockhart H. Lockhart	16	59	41	0	287	5.05	1	3412
17	Charlie Gardiner C. Gardiner	13	84	61	10	199	2.31	8	5178
18	Herb Rheaume H. Rheaume	10	31	20	1	92	2.93	0	1887
19	Ivan Mitchell I. Mitchell	10	22	9	0	88	4.44	0	1190
20	Flat Walsh F. Walsh	3	13	5	4	13	0.96	4	810
21	Frank Brophy F. Brophy	3	21	18	0	148	7.11	0	1249
22	Benny Grant B. Grant	1	5	2	0	5	1.61	1	186
23	Herb Stuart H. Stuart	1	3	2	0	5	1.67	0	180
24	Frenchy Lacroix F. Lacroix	1	5	4	0	16	3.43	0	280
25	Moe Roberts M. Roberts	1	2	1	0	5	3.53	0	85