The Edmonton Oilers couldn't pull it off against the Chicago Blackhawks, 4 to 3, in overtime on January 27, 1999.
1st period
CHI
EDM
Nelson Emerson (EV) assisted by Doug Gilmour and Chris Chelios
1
0
Ed Olczyk (SH) unassisted
2
0
2nd period
CHI
EDM
Tony Amonte (EV) assisted by Doug Zmolek and Doug Gilmour
3
0
Janne Niinimaa (PP) assisted by Ryan Smyth and Doug Weight
3
1
Pat Falloon (EV) assisted by Josef Beranek and Marty McSorley
3
2
3rd period
CHI
EDM
Ryan Smyth (PP) assisted by Boris Mironov and Janne Niinimaa
3
3
OT
CHI
EDM
Tony Amonte (EV) assisted by Doug Gilmour and Nelson Emerson
4
3